Jesus’ miracles weren’t random displays of power. They were part of His strategy for developing disciples.
In this episode, Ben Borgman and Craig Etheredge continue exploring the life and ministry of Jesus by looking at Peter’s calling in Luke 5 and the miraculous catch of fish. Why does this appear to be a second call after Matthew 4? What was Jesus revealing to Peter through the miracle? And how did Jesus use ordinary circumstances, real responsibilities, and moments of hesitation to draw Peter into deeper commitment?
The conversation also connects Peter’s first miraculous catch with his later restoration after the resurrection, revealing a pattern in the way Jesus personally pursued and developed His disciples.
Resources:
- His Way Still Works by Craig Etheredge
- A Harmony of the Gospels by Robert H. Gundry and A. T. Robertson
Overview:
- 00:00 Peter’s full-time commitment to Jesus
- 04:44 Peter’s initial hesitation
- 07:38 Jesus and Peter’s miraculous catch
- 10:46 Peter’s second call by Jesus
- 13:44 Estimating fish value in Galilee
- 17:26 Discount code and book recommendations
Discussion Questions:
- What is the significance of Jesus’ personal approach with Peter when calling him to follow, and how does this inform our understanding of discipleship today?
- In what ways did Peter’s responsibilities and circumstances differ from those of the other disciples, and why is this important when considering his reactions to Jesus’ invitations?
- How do you interpret the difference between Peter’s “first call” (Matthew 4) and his “second call” (Luke 5)? Do you agree they are separate events? Why or why not?
- What can we learn from the fact that Jesus addressed Peter’s practical concerns—his family and finances—before calling him to full-time discipleship?
- How does the miraculous catch of fish serve as more than just a display of Jesus’ power? What message was Jesus conveying to Peter?
- Discuss how remembering God’s past faithfulness (“faith as history”) can lead to stronger steps of faith in your own life.
- The episode suggests Peter may have wavered in his commitment due to practical concerns. How do you relate to moments of wavering in your own faith journey?
- Why do you think Jesus chose to “replay” the miracle of the catch of fish when reinstating Peter after his denial? What does this say about Jesus’ approach to restoration and calling?
- How can leaders today emulate Jesus’ sensitivity to the personal and practical needs of those they disciple?
- After listening to this episode, what steps do you feel called to take in embracing Jesus’ strategy and model of disciple-making in your context?
